Is It Hunger, Appetite or Hungering?
Why knowing the difference changes how you understand eating

You open the fridge, take out the ice cream and start eating.
Perhaps you're hungry. Perhaps you've been thinking about ice cream all evening and finally decided to have some.
Or perhaps you're feeling so agitated that you can't settle, and eating is the only thing you can think of that will make the feeling go away.
Same food. Three very different experiences.
Yet we have a tendency to group them together under familiar descriptions such as overeating, emotional eating or bingeing.
And that's a problem.
Because if we can't distinguish between different eating experiences, how can we begin to understand what's behind them?
The problem with the words we use
In the Weighting for Happiness Project, I've spent years talking with women about their eating. One thing I've discovered is how often women have a detailed understanding of their experiences but lack the vocabulary to describe them.
Take the word bingeing.
It's become part of everyday conversation. We binge on Netflix, chocolate and shopping. But when a woman tells me she's been bingeing on food, I still know very little about what happened.
Was she enjoying something delicious and ate more than she intended? Was she physically hungry? Did she feel unable to stop? Was she trying to escape an uncomfortable feeling?
These distinctions matter. And broad labels can carry shame that makes the experience even harder to discuss.
Three words that open up the conversation: Hunger, Appetite and Hungering
In this week's Before Dieting podcast, we return to Lisa's story.
During our conversation, I asked Lisa to describe three experiences: Hunger, Appetite and Hungering.
Her answers revealed why separating them is so useful.
Hunger is the body's biological need for food. Lisa described the empty feeling she experiences when hungry and wanting something substantial to restore her energy.
Appetite is about wanting food. Lisa talked about seeing chocolates in their colourful wrappers, choosing one she liked and saving it for later. She wasn't hungry. She simply wanted something she enjoyed.
Then we came to Hungering.
Lisa described evenings when she felt agitated and unable to settle. Sometimes a small bowl of ice cream relieved the discomfort.
But she also described a much more intense experience, when everything became overwhelming and she found herself eating ice cream straight from the container.
When I asked what she wanted the eating to achieve, her answer was revealing.
She wanted to get rid of the feeling. To push it down.
She wasn't describing hunger or simply enjoying ice cream.
She was describing eating for relief.
When eating becomes the solution
In the Weighting for Happiness framework, we call this Relief Eating.
It has three distinct phases: Hungering, Eating and Resolution.
Hungering begins with an internal disturbance. During the Eating phase, attention can narrow and the eating can become difficult to interrupt. Resolution occurs when the eating ends and something about the experience changes.
Understanding these phases gives us a way to look more closely at an experience that has often been described with a single, unhelpful label.
Recognising Relief Eating doesn't mean a woman can automatically stop it. But it changes the questions she can ask about what's happening. And that's significant. Because the purpose of eating isn't always nourishment or pleasure. Sometimes food has become the solution to something that has very little to do with food.
What about your own eating?
Think about how often you've tried to change what you eat without understanding why you eat it.
The Weighting for Happiness Food Choices & Eating Patterns diagnostic introduces the Eight Types of Eating and provides structured questions and tools to identify the different patterns operating in your own life.
Instead of applying another set of food rules, you'll begin distinguishing between eating experiences you've previously treated as one problem.
Stop treating all your eating as one problem. Discover what's behind your different eating patterns before you try to change them.
Explore the Food Choices & Eating Patterns diagnostic
Listen to the latest episode of Before Dieting: Lisa's Story. Hunger, Appetite and Hungering.



Comments