What Happens When a Diet Meets Your Eating System

You've decided to lose weight. You've chosen a diet, organised your meals, bought the groceries and made a commitment to follow the instructions.
For a while, everything goes according to plan. You're eating differently, paying attention to portions and seeing results on the scales. Then something changes.
Perhaps work becomes demanding, family routines interfere with meal preparation, or you find yourself eating something you'd promised to avoid.
Gradually, familiar eating patterns return. Before long, you're wondering why you couldn't maintain the changes you'd worked so hard to make.
The usual explanation is that you lost motivation, lacked discipline or simply didn't try hard enough.
But there's another explanation worth considering.
You already have an eating system
Long before you started your latest diet, you'd developed ways of eating that were influenced by your upbringing, relationships, experiences and everyday circumstances.
Some of these influences are easy to recognise.
Perhaps you were taught to finish everything on your plate. Perhaps eating together was an important family expectation, or certain foods were reserved for special occasions.
Other influences are less obvious.
You could have learned that eating provides comfort when you're upset, that refusing food causes offence, or that your own hunger matters less than other people's expectations.
These experiences contribute to what I call your eating system: the collection of rules, learned responses and relationships that influence how and why you eat.
And that system doesn't disappear when you begin a diet.
A diet introduces new rules
Most diets concentrate on changing what you eat. They provide instructions about food choices, portions, restrictions and sometimes meal timing.
But those instructions enter a life where other eating arrangements are already established.
Consider a woman who has always eaten dinner with her family. Her diet requires separate meals, carefully measured portions and additional preparation.
Initially, she manages everything. But as family demands increase, maintaining two different meals becomes difficult. Eventually, she returns to eating what everyone else eats.
She interprets this as a failure of discipline.
Yet the diet introduced requirements that didn't fit comfortably into her existing family arrangements. Understanding that conflict tells us something more useful than simply concluding she should have tried harder.
The same food can serve different purposes
In conversations with women about weight and dieting, I've heard many examples of eating that can't be understood by looking at food alone.
One woman described eating chocolate when she felt frightened. Another ate ice cream when she felt lonely.
Both understood that their eating contributed to their weight concerns. But neither experience could be adequately explained by calories or a lack of willpower.
The relationship between the emotion and the eating was important.
A diet restricting chocolate or ice cream changes what these women are instructed to eat. It doesn't automatically explain why those foods became part of their responses to uncomfortable feelings.
This is why the Weighting for Happiness Project distinguishes eight types of eating. Different eating experiences deserve to be understood on their own terms.
What did your last diet actually change?
Weight regain is complex. Biological responses to dietary restriction, health, circumstances and eating patterns can all contribute.
Understanding your eating system isn't a complete explanation for regain. But it opens up questions that conventional dieting often leaves unanswered.
The diet itself becomes another influence within your eating system. Some of its rules fit with your life, while others conflict with arrangements established over many years.
When the diet ends, those older arrangements can still be operating.
When the Diet meets the eating system
So rather than asking why you couldn't stick to your last diet, consider something different:
Which parts of your eating did that diet change and which parts did you never really look at?
Your answer could reveal information that another set of dieting instructions would never uncover.
Listen to the Podcast Episode here
See the free full explanation of the 8 types of eating here
Checkout the Food Choices and Eating Patterns Diagnostic here
Bronwyn Fletcher is the creator of the Weighting for Happiness Project and host of Before Dieting, a podcast exploring the complexities of eating, dieting and repeated weight regain.


Comments