top of page
Search

What if the food you're trying to give up; is food solving a problem for you?

Bronwyn Fletcher
6 days ago
3 min read
Circle depicting weight regain

Rhonda knew cream buns were contributing to her weight regain. She knew how many calories they contained, and she'd spent years trying to control how many she ate.


Sometimes she cut back on other foods to make room for them in her diet. She could give up plenty of things when she wanted to lose weight. But cream buns were different.


She described herself as having a sweet tooth. It was an explanation she'd lived with for years, although it hadn't helped her understand why she kept returning to this particular food.

And that distinction matters.


When knowing what you eat isn't enough

Most women who have spent years dieting know a great deal about food. They understand calories, portion sizes and which foods contribute to weight gain.


What they often haven't investigated is the purpose different foods serve in their lives. For Rhonda, cream buns were particularly important at the end of a difficult working week. She would stop at the supermarket on her way home, buy several and eat them alone. She loved their sweetness and the coolness of the cream. But the pleasure of eating them was only part of the story.


They helped her settle when she felt overwhelmed. Food solving a problem for her.


As we talked, Rhonda remembered buying cream buns when she was seven, during a frightening period when her parents' marriage was breaking down. Eating had become a way of calming herself.


Fifty years later, the circumstances were different, but the response was remarkably familiar.


Rhonda had never connected those experiences before. She knew about her childhood. She knew cream buns helped her relax. She knew they contributed to her weight regain. What she hadn't recognised was the relationship between them.


Why another diet doesn't answer the question

A diet could tell Rhonda to eat fewer cream buns. It could provide rules for avoiding them or help her rearrange her calorie intake.


But what would happen the next time she felt overwhelmed and wanted the relief those buns provided?


That question had never been part of her dieting plans. The difficulty wasn't simply that she enjoyed cream buns too much. She had come to rely on eating them for something important.


Giving them up meant confronting the need they had been meeting. This is why repeated weight regain deserves more investigation than another assessment of what we're eating.


We need to understand what our eating is doing for us, and why certain patterns persist despite our efforts to change them.


What would you discover about food solving a problem in your own eating?


Your story won't be Rhonda's.


But think about the foods you repeatedly try to restrict, the eating you find difficult to explain, or the choices that seem to contradict your determination to lose weight.


Have you investigated when those patterns began? What circumstances make them more likely? What purpose they serve?


And how do they relate to the other ways you eat throughout an ordinary day?


These aren't questions a food diary or calorie counter is designed to answer.


They're the questions behind the Weighting for Happiness Food Choices & Eating Patterns diagnostic.


Rather than treating all eating as either dieting or overeating, the diagnostic introduces eight distinct types of eating. Through structured questions and practical tools, you investigate how your own eating operates, where different influences intersect and which patterns deserve closer attention.


You don't need another set of food rules to begin.


You need a more complete understanding of the eating those rules are trying to change.



Discover what your eating is doing, make the connections you've been missing and use those findings to make more informed decisions about what needs to change.


Listen to Rhonda's story on my Podcast

Comments


bottom of page